Google and Meta both want your money. Only one of them deserves it on any given day, and it’s usually not the one you picked.
Most local businesses pick an ad platform the way they pick a gym: whichever one a friend swears by. Then they run it on default settings for three months, decide ads do not work for their industry, and go back to referrals. This is the version I walk people through before they spend anything.
Search harvests demand. Social creates it.
Google shows your ad to someone who just typed what they need. Meta shows your ad to someone who was not looking, but looks like the people who buy. One is a net under a waterfall. The other is a flyer in the right mailbox. I wrote the short version in Google or Meta first?
The rule of thumb: if people search for your service by name when they need it, start on Google. If they would want it once they saw it, start on Meta.
What each one really costs
Google charges per click, and the price is set in an auction against every other business bidding on that search. Emergency and high-ticket services cost more per click because the customer is worth more. Meta mostly charges for impressions, so a click is usually cheaper, but the person clicking is earlier in the decision and needs more convincing.
The number that matters is neither one. It is cost per booked job. In Edmonton, that number moves more with how fast you call people back than with which platform you picked.
Three default settings that quietly waste money
- Display Network inside a Search campaign. New Search campaigns can include display placements unless you untick them. Your search budget ends up buying banner ads inside mobile games.
- Location set to presence or interest. Google’s default can show your ad to people who are interested in Edmonton, not just people in it. For a local service business, target people in or regularly in your area.
- Auto-applied recommendations. Google can apply its own suggestions to your account, including new keywords and bid changes. Some are fine. Letting the platform grade its own homework is not.
None of these are hidden. They are just switched on, and nobody tells you.
Budget, creative, negatives, retargeting
Budget. Work backwards from what a customer is worth and how many leads you close, not from a round number that felt safe. A budget too small to collect data costs more than it saves.
Creative. On Meta, the ad itself now does most of the targeting. What you show and what you say tells the system who to go and find.
Negatives. The search terms report shows every search that triggered your ad. Reading it weekly and excluding the junk is the cheapest money you will ever save.
Retargeting. Most people do not buy on the first visit. A small, capped budget aimed at people who already saw your page usually beats another round of cold traffic.
Smart bidding is only as smart as what you feed it
Both platforms lean on automated bidding now. That is fine, as long as you understand the trade. Google’s own page on Smart Bidding is clear that it learns from your conversion data. Feed it form loads and it gets very good at finding people who load forms.
When not to run ads at all
If nobody answers the phone, if the offer is not decided, or if you cannot take on more work, fix that first. Ads multiply whatever is already there, including the problems.
Every note in this pillar
- 1.1 How Much Should a Small Business Spend on Google Ads? The Budget Math Nobody Shows You (coming soon)
- 1.2 Your Ad Creative Is the Targeting Now: How Meta Ads Find Buyers in 2026 (coming soon)
- 1.3 Negative Keywords: The Cheapest Money You’ll Ever Save (coming soon)
- 1.4 Retargeting for Local Businesses: Following People Around the Internet (Politely) (coming soon)
- 1.5 Local Services Ads vs Search Ads: Which Should an Edmonton Contractor Run? (coming soon)
Rather not do this yourself? Have us run your ads. And if your ads already get clicks but not calls, the problem is probably where your ads should actually send people.





